Smokes

Pipes

Aspects also tested pipes using hobitat gold

finely carved pipe      57/62
pipe                    56/61
hookah                  57/62

Aspects summarizes: so to sum up use finely carved pipe or hookah pipes for max heal cigars if bashing and dont require a large heal

Free pipes

kill puffy and smash case, but don't kill puffy, or I'll kill you
Explore the rooms in the palace in Drakhiya

Smokable

Sold out of gold? Try dulce!

All tests were done by a maxed human ficer (level 21 I think?) before traits were available.

All pipe smokes lasted 1 min 45 seconds, while cigars lasted around 3 mins 30 seconds; an exception is the firedrake cigarette, lasting 1 min 45 seconds.

The following were tested with finely carved pipe.

Type of tobacco        hp/sp       cost      how many smokes you get
Hobbitat Gold          57/62       650         5
Arcadian Red           32/36       300         5
Neville Blend          28/33       175         5
parkraz                45/50       450         5
tabaq                  52/56       600         5
Iceforge pipeweed      45/50       200         5
ranger pipeweed        24/28       free..      5
dulce (from Gwot)      54/59       650         5
royal select cigar     52/63       500         5
salamander cigar       32/40
firedrake cigarette    13/17

I've heard the quality of ranger-foraged pipeweed can vary. If anyone smokes a few different clumps and tracks the numbers, please let me know.

Aspects summarizes:

order of heal best are gold, dulche, tabaq
but best value...specially good for lower lvls is iceforge pipeweed by a long shot.

Tinuviel notes that cigars are weightless (once you ditch the boxes) and, being a weak half elf, prefers them to juggling pouches and packets and pipes.

Thanks are due to Aspects for giving over his lungs for smoking science!